Nolan's Bane: How to NOT Make a Villain

Ok, so finally I have watched "The Dark Knight Rises" and Oh BOY!...



...I really don't know what to think about this film.

Is not by any means a perfect film as a lot of people expected, I don't know yet if I could call it a Great film or a Good film.

But there are certain issues that really bothered me about this final part of the Nolan trilogy. And I'm not going to complain about the logistics, scientific facts or physics of the movie, like:

How Does Bruce Wayne Get Back to Gotham?

Why Does a Prison Exist Where People Can Possibly Climb To Freedom? 

The Unrealistic way that the bomb exploded or the unrealistic way that the bomb functioned.

because I know that in that territory the film is pretty flawed.

If you want to see more technical and logic problems of the film, here you go.

But you know, almost all action films have these type of flaws, specially superhero movies. But if you think about it; there are a lot of great films with a lot of technical and unrealistic flaws and they are still great films indeed, and I guess there are flaws that not even the almighty Nolan could surpass.

But anyway, as a lot of wise people said "Just ignore the technical stuff and enjoy the story", and that's what I always do, but still there are serious factors about the story that annoyed me.

There are 3 major factors about the story that simply made me consider this film the weakest of the trilogy.

1.- The obsession to make Batman a Messianic martyr of the people. Instead of the dark, underground, mysterious and symbolic vigilante figure that he really is.

2.- I feel that the film doesn't know what it wants to do or in what it wants to become, TDKR stars mainly as a noir film but eventually right in the middle of the film, it wants to become a dystopian film all of a sudden, with really poor results, that’s because the overall dystopian Gotham is not developed at all. We don’t even see the true nature of this environment within the people of Gotham, we just see cops trap inside a tunnel, bad guys with tanks in the streets and that’s it. There’s no development in the environment, you don’t really see the hell and chaos you should see. If you want to make this kind of environment effective you need to give it a lot of exposure and development. That’s why I think it would had been so much nicer and badass to start the film already in this dystopian state, develop it throughout the whole film and explain what happened with flashbacks. Instead of building this forced dystopia that nobody knew how it really worked and we only get to see until the third act.

And third and most important, the villain: Bane.



I have to admit that the Bane of TDKR is probably the most disappointing villain of the last couple of years. And here's the reason why: Trough out the hole bloody film we hear about Bane, all the stuff that he has done, all the stuff that he is doing, all the things that he has planned, they build the character as a truly bad ass brutal mastermind and that's perfect, that's exactly what they have to do, specially with his background.

I mean, uuuuh he's Bane, he escaped from a prison climbing a brutal enormous cylindrical wall and he has been the only to reach the top, and he did this while he was just a little kid.

uuuuh he's Bane, his the son of Ra's Al Ghul.

uuuuh he's Bane, he has an eternal vendetta against Batman.

uuuuh he's Bane, he's the leader of the League of Shadows.

uuuuh he's Bane, he planned all this mayhem.

They built this character as probably the greatest villain of Batman ever and suddenly, is like... uh remember all the things that we  said about this guy... well... it wasn't him... yes... yes that's right it was that new chick over there... yeah the one who is suddenly so important in the third act of the story and we pretty much ignored her throughout the whole film giving her almost no proper character development... yes... she's the one... she did all that.... uh, what did Bane did then?... uh... well, he... he... helped her.

And then BOOOM , this great and epic villain that they were able to form in this entire film is dead by a single motorcycle gun shoot, and he dies in both a physical and spiritual way. When a villain dies at least he still lives in a spiritual way when you remember all the things that he did, but we cannot do that with Bane, because he wasn't the true mastermind behind all of this, he wasn't that epic villain that you thought he was, he was basically just a goon, the thing that you least expected from him.

Is not the first time Nolan does this, he did it in Batman Begins with Ra's Al Ghul, but at least he did in a reverted form you know: when you have a really cool villain, but you think he's just a goon of someone else but actually it turns out that he's the actual leader and it's even more badass than you thought, that way really works, Ben from LOST is a living example. But don't do it the other way around.

That was the thing that just killed the character for me and a big part of the film, I know that I'm complaining a lot with this but in a superhero film, the villain is the most important character in the story. And I just hate when they fool you with the identity of the true villain. I mean that's ok in a Mystery, Thriller or Noir story, but not in an epic action superhero film, specially since you have promoted that villain in the marketing of your movie like crazy!!!